Head to head
Arden Deep Seat 24 x 24 vs Greendale Deep Seat Azure (2026)
Arden Outdoor Foam Deep Seat Cushion Set 24 x 24 vs Greendale Deep Seat Cushion Set Azure compared: foam, pattern, reversibility, and which set you should buy.
#1 in our rankings · Best overall
Arden Selections Outdoor Foam Deep Seat Cushion Set 24 x 24, Tan Diamond Trellis
Best for: Deep seat patio chairs, sofas, and couches where a firm foam seat and a tall pillow back are wanted.
#5 in our rankings · Best patterned deep seat
Greendale Home Fashions Outdoor Reversible 2-Piece Deep Seat Cushion Set, Azure
Best for: Deep seat chairs where a bold blue pattern is wanted, and buyers who like a reversible cushion they can flip.
Our recommendation
Buy the Arden Deep Seat Set in Tan Diamond Trellis if you want firm foam that holds its shape through daily sitting: the high-density foam and the tall pillow back are the better buy for a chair used every day. Buy the Greendale Deep Seat Set in Azure if you want pattern and reversibility: the blue and white tile print lifts a plain patio set, and either face can sit outwards. Both are two-piece deep seat sets, so the choice is support against pattern.
Foam against fibre-soft fill
The Arden set is filled with high-density polyurethane foam, which keeps the seat thick and supportive instead of flattening. The Greendale set is softer, which feels plush at first but flattens a little faster under daily use. For a chair that sees regular sitting, the foam is the better buy. For a chair used occasionally, the softer Greendale set is comfortable enough.
Pattern and reversibility
The Greendale set is reversible, so either face can sit outwards, which doubles the usable life of the look and hides a stain in a pinch. The Arden set is not reversible, but the tan diamond trellis pattern is calmer than the busy blue tile print, so it suits a wider range of patio colours. Pattern buyers should choose the Greendale, and plain buyers should choose the Arden.
What they share
Both are two-piece deep seat sets for standard deep seat chairs, both use outdoor polyester fabric, and both need the frame measured before ordering, since a wide chair will leave gaps at the sides. Neither is a dining chair pad: both are too large for a standard dining chair, and both need a deep seat frame to sit properly.
Choose Arden Selections Outdoor Foam Deep Seat Cushion Set 24 x 24, Tan Diamond Trellis if…
- You sit on the chair every day
- You want foam that holds its shape
- You prefer a calm trellis pattern
Choose Greendale Home Fashions Outdoor Reversible 2-Piece Deep Seat Cushion Set, Azure if…
- You want a bold blue pattern
- You like a reversible cushion you can flip
- The chair sees occasional use
Spec-by-spec comparison
| Spec | Arden Selections Outdoor Foam Deep Seat Cushion Set 24 x 24, Tan Diamond Trellis | Greendale Home Fashions Outdoor Reversible 2-Piece Deep Seat Cushion Set, Azure |
|---|---|---|
| Price tier | Mid-range | Mid-range |
| Seat bottom | 24 x 24 x 5.75 inches | - |
| Pillow back | 24 x 21 x 6.5 inches | - |
| Fill | High-density polyurethane foam | - |
| Cover | Printed polyester | - |
| Firmness | Firm | - |
| Ties | Two sets on the seat bottom | - |
| Set | - | 2-piece reversible deep seat set |
| Pattern | - | Azure, blue and white tile |
| Fabric | - | Durable outdoor polyester |
| Model | - | AZ7825-INDIGO |
| Use | - | Indoor and outdoor |
| Best for | Deep seat patio chairs, sofas, and couches where a firm foam seat and a tall pillow back are wanted. | Deep seat chairs where a bold blue pattern is wanted, and buyers who like a reversible cushion they can flip. |
| Skip if | Your chair frame is smaller than 24 inches, or you want a soft fibre fill rather than firm foam. | You want a plain solid colour, or you need the thick foam support of the Arden set. |
Strengths and limitations
Arden Selections Outdoor Foam Deep Seat Cushion Set 24 x 24, Tan Diamond Trellis
Strengths
- The high-density USA-made foam keeps the seat thick and supportive instead of flattening after a few weeks of sitting.
- The pillow back measures 24 inches wide by 21 inches long and 6.5 inches thick, so it fills a deep seat chair properly.
- Two sets of ties on the seat bottom hold the cushion in place on the chair, and the printed polyester fabric resists fading.
Limitations
- At 24 inches square it is too wide for standard dining chairs and smaller patio chairs, so measure the frame first.
- The foam arrives compressed and needs time to expand to its full thickness before first use.
- The firm feel suits buyers who like support, but it will feel hard to anyone expecting a soft fibre cushion.
Greendale Home Fashions Outdoor Reversible 2-Piece Deep Seat Cushion Set, Azure
Strengths
- The Azure tile pattern in blue and white lifts a plain patio set and hides small marks better than a solid pale colour.
- The two-piece set is reversible, so either face can sit outwards, which doubles the usable life of the look.
- The durable outdoor polyester fabric is made to withstand the elements, and Greendale has made home products in the US since 1954.
Limitations
- The pattern is busy up close, so buyers who want a calm solid should choose the Arden or Montlake sets instead.
- The seat is softer than the Arden foam set, so it flattens a little faster under daily use.
- The set is sized for standard deep seat chairs, so measure the frame before ordering, since a wide chair will leave gaps at the sides.
How they fit the wider field
- Arden Selections Outdoor Foam Deep Seat Cushion Set 24 x 24, Tan Diamond Trellis: ranked #1 (Best overall) in The Best Outdoor Cushions. Read the full Arden Selections Outdoor Foam Deep Seat Cushion Set 24 x 24, Tan Diamond Trellis review.
- Greendale Home Fashions Outdoor Reversible 2-Piece Deep Seat Cushion Set, Azure: ranked #5 (Best patterned deep seat) in The Best Outdoor Cushions.
Neither one quite right? The full rankings cover 10 picks matched to different buyers.
Made your call?
Questions, answered
Which one lasts longer?
The Arden set, because the high-density foam holds its shape longer than the softer Greendale fill. Both fabrics handle sun and rain well, but the foam is what decides how long the set stays comfortable.
Can I use either on a dining chair?
No. Both are sized for deep seat chairs, and both will overhang a standard dining chair. For dining chairs, look at the Arden 20 by 20 inch dining cushion or the Pillow Perfect 19 by 19 inch pads instead.
Which one is better for a sunny patio?
Both handle sun well, but the Arden trellis in tan shows fading less than the Greendale blue tile, which is a deeper colour. For the sunniest spot, the Arden is the safer buy.